Skip to content
Calm Thoughts

Why Moises Caicedo Was Sent Off While Bentancur Avoided One: A Tale of Seeming Lack of Uniformity.

A Chelsea side down to ten men The Blues hold Arsenal to a draw in feisty capital clash.

Chelsea boss Maresca was feeling aggrieved. This frustration stemmed not from the dismissal of Moises Caicedo against Arsenal, but over what he perceived to be a glaring lack of consistency from the officials.

You can see his perspective. Last month, Tottenham midfielder Bentancur was booked for a foul on Reece James, a ruling the video review system agreed with. However, when the Ecuadorian was given a yellow for a seemingly similar tackle on Mikel Merino, the official in the booth stepped in to upgrade it to a straight dismissal.

"That is a sending-off offence, however, why was Bentancur's against Reece James not a dismissal? So us, as a manager, we find it difficult to comprehend why they judge in a dissimilar manner," the manager questioned.

Analyzing the Distinction?

Ultimately, rulings are often influenced upon the specific official on VAR duty—a factor that renders true consistency very difficult.

No two fouls is ever the same, and there were nuanced distinctions between the two challenges. Bentancur was primarily stepping in, while the Chelsea man jumped a little and his point of contact was slightly higher.

Furthermore, there was a visible twist of the midfielder's joint, a sign a video referee watches for to signal excessive force, and his boot was shifted on the pitch surface.

In Bentancur's case, the league's independent review panel backed the caution for Bentancur by a margin of 4-1, and agreed without dissent no review overturn "on the basis that the tackle was near the ground, just slightly late and careless".

The KMI panel will undoubtedly back the decision to dismiss Caicedo, but it may not be long before a similar challenge of its type is deemed just a yellow card.

Did the VAR Tell the On-Field Official to Show a Caution?

Moises Caicedo faces a suspension for three matches following his dismissal against Arsenal.

Events on the field appeared somewhat perplexing initially. Did official Taylor being advised to caution the player so the foul could be reviewed?

There is a far simpler reason.

The referee allowed play to continue for the attacking team as the possession was with Eberechi Eze. When it went out for a throw, the official returned to book Caicedo, who was receiving treatment. Referees are instructed to delay until an player at fault is standing before displaying a disciplinary sanction.

So, the delay was not because the video review process; it was since the player was with the physio.

The VAR Brooks may have reached the determination that there was sufficient severity for a dismissal, but he has to wait for the referee to make clear his on-field ruling. The moment Taylor brandished a caution, the video official immediately sent him to the review screen because the check had already taken place during the treatment.

England Rejects Red Card Review

Also on Sunday, for just the second instance in the Premier League, a referee rejected a red card review at the on-field review screen.

The referee did not award a free-kick against the player, so in contrast to the Chelsea incident, the restart was a free-kick to Aston Villa. The VAR, Bell, believed that the way Arias launched himself with studs showing endangered Boubacar Kamara's safety.

Yet, the challenger was off the floor and took a risk, making contact with the top of Kamara's boot. It did not have the level of intensity typically required for a straight red, even if it was not a great challenge.

Was There a Case For Chelsea's Goal to Be Ruled Out for an Offside Offence?

The VAR decided that the Argentine did not interfere on the Arsenal backline when Chalobah scored the opening goal for Chelsea.

Once again, and another set of debatable rulings on player positioning.

One potential offside on Chelsea's goal appears to have escaped significant scrutiny.

Reece James floated a set-piece in from the left flank, and Trevoh Chalobah guided a header into the net.

However, there existed a potential issue. Enzo Fernandez was stood in an illegal position and was in close proximity to Arsenal's Piero Hincapie and Mosquera.

Did Fernandez influence the actions of either defender? If the Chelsea player not been there, would there have been a greater opportunity of preventing the goal?

He did not try to play the ball, and while he was not physically contesting with one defender, he had his arm on Hincapie's back.

One could argue a compelling argument for an offside call, so it returns us to a question of uniform interpretation yet again.

Should The Defender Have Seen Red for an Use of the Elbow?

Piero Hincapie was in the lineup for the Gunners with both centre-backs unavailable through injury.

It was shortly after the Caicedo red card. Hincapie went up for a ball with the Chelsea player, and the Blues man sustained contact through contact by the arm on his head.

"I questioned the official, he told me that it was not an elbow offence," the Chelsea manager said. "So, this is what they ruled. He had a facial injury, with ice at the interval. But they judge in a separate manner."

Match officials are advised not to make judgements based on a potential injury, even if it undoubtedly happens. A player can sustain a gash or a bruise from various types of contact, so it would not be a sound basis.

As with dangerous tackles, officials have a set of criteria they consider for a possible elbow.

  • Was it an unnatural way of challenging for a aerial ball?
  • Did the player a clenched fist, which indicates aggression?
  • Was the elbow swung or raised to generate power?

In this case, none were present, so a yellow card was considered appropriate.

The writer

Matthew Simmons

A certified mindfulness coach and meditation teacher with over a decade of experience helping people find inner peace through simple, effective practices.

Calm Thoughts

Type to search articles.